Performance indicators for the Carmel short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Carmel.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
STRs are explicitly permitted under Indiana HB 1035 with no caps or registration fees, but the primary residence requirement significantly limits investment opportunities to owner-occupied properties only. The Special Exception Application process through the Board of Zoning Appeals adds moderate regulatory complexity and compliance requirements that investors must navigate.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Carmel, IN
Carmel is a city in Hamilton County, Indiana, situated in the heart of the Indianapolis metropolitan area. Home to approximately 100,000 residents, it has earned a reputation as one of the most affluent and thoughtfully planned suburbs in the Midwest, with a charming blend of small-town atmosphere and big-city amenities. The city is perhaps best known for its distinctive urban design — it boasts more roundabouts than any other city in the United States — and serves as a popular base for visitors attending major Indianapolis events, located roughly fifteen miles north of downtown Indianapolis.
The Carmel Arts & Design District forms the cultural heart of the city, a walkable downtown area filled with art galleries, specialty shops, and independently owned restaurants. It is also home to the Palladium at the Center for the Performing Arts, a striking concert venue that hosts national touring acts, Broadway productions, and community performances throughout the year.
Just steps from the Arts District, the Monon Trail offers miles of paved pathway that cyclists, joggers, and walkers enjoy year-round. The trail stretches south from Carmel into Indianapolis and continues northward through Hamilton County, making it both a local recreational asset and a regional connector for outdoor enthusiasts.
A short drive east in neighboring Fishers, Conner Prairie is an expansive interactive history park where visitors can explore Indiana's past through costumed interpreters, historic buildings, and hands-on experiences. A bit further north in Westfield, Grand Park has become one of the largest youth sports campuses in the country, drawing families and athletic teams for tournaments nearly every weekend of the year.
For those seeking a quieter outdoor escape, Coxhall Gardens offers about 125 acres of themed gardens, a central lake, and an amphitheater just minutes from downtown Carmel, providing a peaceful counterpoint to the city's busier venues.
Carmel's combination of cultural amenities, abundant outdoor recreation, family-friendly atmosphere, and proximity to Indianapolis makes it an especially strong market for short-term rentals. The city draws a steady stream of visitors attending performing arts events, youth sports tournaments, and major Indianapolis occasions such as the Indy 500, while also appealing to travelers seeking a polished Midwestern getaway with easy access to the broader region.