Performance indicators for the Overgaard short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Overgaard.
Loading top listings...
Very Investor friendly
Overgaard explicitly allows short‑term rentals citywide, with straightforward licensing (state TPT, county registration, minimal municipal requirements) and no caps, and the official tone is low‑regulatory and supportive.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Overgaard, AZ
Overgaard is a small, high-elevation community in Navajo County, in the east-central part of Arizona, sitting just below the Mogollon Rim on the Sitgreaves National Forest. The unincorporated community, often paired with its neighbor Heber, has a population of roughly 2,800 to 3,000 residents and carries the feel of a quiet mountain village. It is best known as a summer escape from the desert heat and as a gateway to the outdoor recreation of the White Mountains region. The nearest major city is Phoenix, located about 170 miles to the southwest and roughly a three-hour drive, while Flagstaff lies approximately 90 miles to the northwest along State Route 260.
The Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest wraps around Overgaard, and the community serves as a convenient base for travelers exploring the surrounding ponderosa pine country. Hiking trails, scenic drives, and campgrounds are accessible within a short drive of town, and the forest's high country draws visitors year-round for its cool summer temperatures and, in winter, for occasional snowfall. The forest stretches across much of east-central Arizona, with Overgaard sitting along its western edge.
Just a few miles south of Overgaard, Willow Springs Lake offers a small but popular spot for trout fishing, canoeing, and picnicking. The lake sits in a quiet forest setting and is a frequent stop for families and anglers looking for an easy day trip from town. Other nearby reservoirs, including Bear Canyon Lake and Chevelon Canyon Lake, offer additional fishing and shoreline recreation within roughly a 30-minute drive.
To the north, the Mogollon Rim forms one of the most dramatic geological features in Arizona, a long limestone and sandstone escarpment that drops steeply toward the lower deserts to the south. The rim is lined with overlooks, hiking paths, and forest roads, and portions of it can be reached from Overgaard in under an hour. Further afield, Petrified Forest National Park lies about two hours to the north and offers a completely different landscape of colorful badlands and ancient fossilized logs.
Overgaard's combination of cool mountain air, forest access, and proximity to both the Mogollon Rim and the small lakes of the Sitgreaves high country makes it a natural fit for travelers seeking a quieter alternative to Arizona's busier resort towns. Its location along the route between Phoenix and the White Mountains gives short-term rental owners a steady mix of summer weekenders, autumn leaf-peepers, and hunters and anglers who return year after year.