Performance indicators for the Pewaukee short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Pewaukee.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
STRs are permitted but limited to stays of 6–29 days and only 180 rental days per year, plus fire/building/health inspections and annual renewal, which significantly curtails operating flexibility and makes compliance routine rather than prohibitive.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Pewaukee, WI
Pewaukee is a city in Waukesha County, Wisconsin, home to roughly 14,000 residents who enjoy a quiet suburban setting with the kind of water access that is increasingly rare this close to a major metro. The community wraps around the southern shore of Pewaukee Lake, one of the larger inland lakes in southeastern Wisconsin, and that shoreline identity shapes much of the local vibe: a mix of year-round residents, weekend lake-house owners, and visitors who come for fishing, ice fishing in winter, and the cluster of lakeside restaurants and parks that line the water. Pewaukee sits about 20 miles west of Milwaukee, putting it comfortably within a short drive of a major city while feeling distinctly more small-town and water-oriented than its bigger neighbor.
The lake itself is the town's defining feature and the main reason most visitors end up here. Pewaukee Lake covers roughly 2,400 acres and is well known for musky and walleye fishing, with a public beach, boat launches, and the popular lakefront Village Park on the south end. Sunset cruises, pontoon rentals, and a long-standing local tradition of ice-fishing shanties on the frozen surface in January and February give the area a year-round draw. The lake is essentially the front yard of downtown Pewaukee, so visitors can park once and walk between the water, the small commercial district, and several lakefront dining spots.
Just to the south and west of town, the Kettle Moraine State Forest (Southern Unit) offers a dramatically different landscape of rolling hills, kettles, and moraines left by the last glaciation. The forest's trails, including segments of the Ice Age National Scenic Trail, are popular with hikers and mountain bikers, and it is roughly a 15 to 25 minute drive from most parts of Pewaukee. This makes it easy for short-term rental guests to pair a morning on the lake with an afternoon hike among the drumlins and eskers.
A few minutes south of Pewaukee, the city of Waukesha serves as the county seat and adds a second layer of things to do. Its restored riverfront along the Fox River, a historic downtown, and the Frame Park area give visitors a more urban flavor, while Cutler Park and the surrounding trails extend the outdoor options. And for guests who want the full slate of a big-city weekend, Milwaukee is an easy drive east via Interstate 94, with its lakefront museums, the Third Ward dining scene, and Brewers games at American Family Field, all reachable in roughly 30 minutes depending on traffic.
For short-term rental owners, Pewaukee hits a useful middle ground. It feels like a destination in its own right thanks to the lake, yet it functions equally well as a base for guests exploring the wider southeastern Wisconsin region. The combination of a recognized natural amenity, proximity to a major metro, and access to both the Kettle Moraine and the Waukesha County seat gives the area a breadth of appeal that supports both weekend leisure travelers and longer family or reunion stays.