Performance indicators for the Mount Gretna short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Mount Gretna.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
Palmyra explicitly permits STRs across most residential uses with clear, well-defined rules and a known permitting process, but requires multiple licenses (county hotel tax, state sales tax, $500K liability), annual non‑transferable permits, a 24/7 local contact able to respond in one hour, safety devices, sewage‑tied occupancy caps (2+3 up to 15), and inspections that can suspend operations (especially for pools), creating moderate compliance effort and ongoing operational constraints.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Mount Gretna, PA
Mount Gretna is a tiny, storybook borough tucked into the rolling, wooded hills of southern Lebanon County, Pennsylvania, with a year-round population of only around 200 residents. The community has the feel of a Victorian summer enclave, with narrow lanes, quaint cottages, and a leafy canopy that feels a world away from busy interstates. Best known as a historic chautauqua and arts colony founded in the 1880s by iron magnate Robert Coleman, Mount Gretna still functions as a cultural retreat and a gateway to the larger Pennsylvania Dutch Country and state game lands surrounding it. It sits roughly ninety miles west of Philadelphia, about thirty miles east of Harrisburg, and only a short drive south of Lancaster, making it a surprisingly central base for exploring a wide swath of south-central Pennsylvania.
Just a few minutes from the heart of the borough, Mount Gretna Lake and Beach is a small but beloved summer escape with a sandy swimming beach, paddleboats, and picnic areas shaded by old oaks. The lake draws families from across the region on warm weekends, and its calm, spring-fed waters and casual concessions give the area a nostalgic resort atmosphere that has barely changed in a century.
A short drive to the east lies the Cornwall Iron Furnace, once the largest iron furnace in the American colonies and now preserved as a National Historic Landmark. Visitors can tour the restored stack, the charcoal house, and the worker cottages, getting a tangible sense of the industry that put this corner of Pennsylvania on the colonial map. It is one of the most important industrial-heritage sites in the state and an easy half-day excursion from Mount Gretna.
To the south, the rolling farmland and covered bridges of Lancaster County unfold in every direction, with the genteel streets of Lititz, the markets of Lancaster City, and the working Amish farms of Bird-in-Hand all reachable in roughly thirty to forty-five minutes. In the opposite direction, the more rugged ridges of the Lebanon Valley and the Tuscarora State Forest offer hiking, trout fishing, and quiet country roads that feel far removed from the densely settled parts of the Mid-Atlantic.
For short-term-rental owners, Mount Gretna is a quietly compelling market. Its compact footprint, strong summer cultural calendar, and proximity to three very different visitor economies — the Pennsylvania Dutch Country, the Hershey-area attractions to the north, and the state forests and game lands on its doorstep — give it an unusually broad draw. Rentals here tend to appeal to guests seeking a slower, more nostalgic pace, which translates into a loyal repeat-visitor base and steady shoulder-season interest in the arts and outdoor recreation that define the borough.