Performance indicators for the Erie short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Erie.
Loading top listings...
Very Investor friendly
Erie explicitly permits STRs in numerous residential, commercial, and waterfront districts with a clear, three‑stage process (zoning certificate, inspection, licensing); occupancy/behavior rules are moderate and no caps or high fees are reported, keeping compliance predictable.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Erie, PA
Erie is a port city situated in northwestern Pennsylvania along the southern shore of Lake Erie, where it serves as the seat of Erie County. With a city population of roughly 95,000 residents, it carries the easygoing character of a mid-sized lakeside town that has long balanced its industrial heritage with a growing reputation as a four-season outdoor destination. The city is best known as the home of Presque Isle State Park, a sandy peninsula that curves out into the lake, and it functions as a natural gateway to Lake Erie recreation, Pennsylvania's burgeoning wine country, and the broader Great Lakes region. Erie sits about 90 miles southwest of Buffalo, New York, and roughly 100 miles northeast of Cleveland, Ohio, with Pittsburgh located approximately 125 miles to the south.
Presque Isle State Park is the signature attraction of the area, drawing visitors year-round to its 3,200 acres of beaches, trails, and bay waters. The peninsula offers swimming in the summer, fall foliage drives and bird migration viewing, cross-country skiing in the winter, and a scenic 13-mile driving loop that makes it accessible in any season. Located just minutes from downtown Erie, the park anchors much of the city's tourism economy and provides an immediate natural draw for any short-term rental within a short drive.
Just steps from the bayfront, the Erie Maritime Museum preserves the region's nautical past and serves as the home port for the U.S. Brig Niagara, a reconstruction of the flagship Oliver Hazard Perry commanded during the War of 1812 Battle of Lake Erie. Visitors can tour the ship seasonally and explore exhibits on the region's shipbuilding and shipping history, making this a popular stop for those interested in both maritime heritage and hands-on experiences on the water.
For families and amusement-park enthusiasts, Waldameer Park & Water World sits on the lakefront just outside the entrance to Presque Isle and has been operating since 1896. It combines a classic wooden roller coaster, modern steel coasters, and a sizable water park complex, making it a reliable seasonal anchor for family travel. A short drive north of the city, the Lake Erie Wine Country trail winds through rolling vineyards and tasting rooms that have helped transform the regional agricultural landscape, offering a quieter complement to the lakefront attractions.
Erie makes a compelling base for short-term rentals because it pairs affordable, varied lodging options with a genuinely diverse set of draws, from beaches and amusement parks to maritime history and vineyard touring. Its position within a few hours' drive of three other sizable cities, combined with the natural centerpiece of Presque Isle and the lake itself, gives the destination year-round appeal and a steady rotation of visitor types, from summer beachgoers to fall leaf-peepers and winter snow seekers.