Performance indicators for the Conesus short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Conesus.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
Conesus permits short-term rentals citywide but requires a Special Use Permit, annual renewal, inspections, and county occupancy tax collection—creating moderate compliance costs without clear caps or zoning limits; the overall tone is supportive and the market is described as a low-regulation environment.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Conesus, NY
Conesus is a small town in Livingston County in the western Finger Lakes region of New York, with a population of roughly 2,400 residents spread across rolling farmland, wooded hills, and the shoreline of its namesake lake. The community has the feel of a quiet rural hamlet, with a single main crossroads in the hamlet of Conesus, working farms, and seasonal cottages tucked along the water. It is best known as a gateway to Conesus Lake, one of the smaller Finger Lakes, and sits roughly 30 miles south of Rochester, making it a reachable escape from the city for weekenders and outdoor travelers.
Conesus Lake anchors the town's identity and is the main draw for visitors. The lake runs about eight miles long and is popular for fishing, small-craft boating, kayaking, and lakeside picnicking, with public access points and a handful of marinas along its eastern and western shores. Cottages and lake houses ring the water, and the calm, relatively shallow lake is a favorite for families and paddlers during the warmer months. More information is available on its Wikipedia page.
Just south of town, Hemlock Lake and the surrounding Hemlock-Canadice State Forest offer a quieter, more undeveloped slice of the Finger Lakes. Hemlock is the more remote of the two, with limited public access because it serves as a drinking water source for Rochester, but Canadice Lake and the state forest's trail network are open to hikers, mountain bikers, and cross-country skiers who want a more solitary outing than the busier Finger Lakes further east.
A roughly 30-minute drive to the south brings guests to Letchworth State Park, which spans the Genesee River gorge and is widely regarded as one of the most scenic state parks in the country, earning the nickname "the Grand Canyon of the East." The park features three major waterfalls, dramatic cliffs, a historic railway trestle, whitewater rafting in spring, and more than 60 miles of hiking trails. Visitors can learn more at its official page.
A short drive north brings guests to Geneseo, the Livingston County seat and home to the SUNY Geneseo campus. The village has a tidy main street with locally owned restaurants, coffee shops, and 19th-century architecture, and it hosts a lively atmosphere year-round thanks to the college population. From Geneseo, day trips open up to the larger Finger Lakes wine trails, including those around Canandaigua and Keuka, as well as the town of Avon to the north.
Conesus works well as a short-term-rental base because it offers genuine Finger Lakes scenery without the crowds and price tags of the more famous lakes further east. Guests can wake up to lake views, hike or paddle by day, and easily drive to a major state park, a small college town with restaurants and events, and Rochester for urban amenities, all from a single quiet rural address.