Performance indicators for the Toms River short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Toms River.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
STRs are technically legal but heavily constrained: mainland properties effectively prohibited by a 30-day minimum stay, and barrier island STRs are permitted only seasonally (Apr–Nov) with mandatory annual inspections/certificates, occupancy limits, and advertising registration—compliance is doable but strict enough to deter many investors.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Toms River, NJ
Toms River is a township in Ocean County, New Jersey, situated on the Atlantic coastal plain and serving as the county seat. With a population of approximately 95,000, it functions as a commercial and civic hub for a broad stretch of the Jersey Shore, a region of barrier-island beaches, bayside communities, and the inland Pine Barrens. The township carries a relaxed, family-oriented seaside character shaped by boating, fishing, and a strong summer tourism economy. It lies roughly sixty to seventy miles south of New York City and about sixty miles east of Philadelphia, making it a convenient base for weekenders and second-home owners seeking beach access with reasonable proximity to two major metropolitan areas.
Just east of the township, Island Beach State Park offers nearly ten miles of relatively undeveloped oceanfront, with swimming, surf fishing, and nature trails winding through maritime forest and dunes. The drive from central Toms River is roughly fifteen to twenty minutes, and the park's preserved character sets it apart from the more developed boardwalk towns that lie further north along the barrier islands.
North along the shore, the borough of Seaside Heights and its neighboring boardwalk communities draw visitors for arcades, amusement rides, and a lively summer scene. These barrier-island towns are typically reached within twenty to twenty-five minutes from Toms River, depending on bay-bridge traffic, and they tend to see peak demand from late June through Labor Day weekend.
Inland, Toms River sits on the edge of the Pinelands National Reserve, a million-acre expanse of pine-oak forest, cedar swamps, and slow-moving rivers that has been designated a UNESCO Biosphere Reserve. Hiking, kayaking, and canoeing are all within a short drive of the township, and the unique ecosystem gives the area a distinct natural identity that extends well beyond its beaches.
The township is also within roughly thirty minutes of Barnegat Lighthouse State Park in Barnegat Light, home to the historic "Old Barney" lighthouse at the northern tip of Long Beach Island, where visitors can climb the tower for views over Island Beach and Barnegat Inlet.
Toms River's blend of accessible beaches, the Pinelands, family-friendly communities, and proximity to both the New York and Philadelphia markets makes it a versatile base for short-term rentals. Owners can position properties to capture summer beach traffic, off-season nature travelers, and the steady year-round demand generated by regional events, hospital visits, and families relocating to explore the Jersey Shore.