Performance indicators for the Sussex short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Sussex.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Sussex Borough has no published STR ordinance in the provided documents, making legality and the permitting process ambiguous while New Jersey gives municipalities broad STR authority; investors must verify zoning, safety and business requirements, and any local taxes, and the county context shows strict caps, permits, inspections and fees in neighboring towns. The resulting uncertainty, potential compliance costs and risk of future restrictive rules create a challenging investment environment.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Sussex, NJ
Sussex is a small borough and the county seat of Sussex County, nestled in the far northwestern corner of New Jersey in the state's Skylands Region. With a population of roughly 2,100 residents, the borough has the unhurried feel of a rural county seat, surrounded by rolling farmland, the Kittatinny Mountains, and the wooded ridges that form part of New Jersey's northern border with New York and Pennsylvania. It serves as a low-key gateway to some of the most dramatic scenery in the state — the Delaware Water Gap, the Appalachian Trail, and the highest elevations in New Jersey all lie within a short drive. From New York City, Sussex sits about 60 miles to the northwest, generally a 90-minute to two-hour drive depending on traffic.
One of the closest marquee attractions is High Point State Park, about 15 minutes north of the borough. The park is home to the High Point Monument, which stands at the highest elevation in New Jersey at 1,803 feet, and offers panoramic views of the tri-state area, plus miles of hiking trails, a lake for swimming and fishing, and a campground that draws visitors year-round.
Just a few miles south of Sussex in the town of Ogdensburg lies the Sterling Hill Mining Museum, set on the site of a former zinc mine that operated for more than 130 years. The museum is renowned for its fluorescent mineral collection and underground mine tours, and it draws families and rockhounds from across the region. Its proximity to the borough — roughly a ten-minute drive — makes it an easy half-day outing for visitors staying in the area.
About 20 minutes southeast of Sussex, in Beemerville, Space Farms Zoo & Museum has been a roadside fixture of northwestern New Jersey for nearly a century, with a collection of more than 500 animals ranging from bears and big cats to American bison, alongside an antique car and motorcycle museum. It remains one of the most family-friendly stops in the Skylands and a recognizable name for travelers planning a country weekend in the region.
To the west, roughly 35 to 40 minutes from Sussex, the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area anchors a sweeping stretch of the Delaware River where Pennsylvania and New Jersey meet. The recreation area offers river trips, hiking into the Water Gap itself, and access to a long stretch of the Appalachian Trail, making it a natural day trip for outdoor-focused guests.
Sussex works well as a short-term rental base precisely because it combines small-town quiet with access to a deep bench of outdoor and family attractions. Visitors who want to hike, mine for minerals, spot wildlife, or simply spend evenings watching the sun set over the Kittatinny ridges find an appealing mix of convenience and escape — close enough to the New York metropolitan area for an easy weekend, yet far enough to feel a world apart.