Performance indicators for the Flemington short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Flemington.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
STRs are likely permitted in many zones as accessory uses and lack hard caps or a separate licensing regime, but operators must navigate zoning approvals, NTC/NOC requirements for commercial spaces, and standard fire/UCC/health/tax compliance—creating moderate, manageable complexity rather than a prohibitive barrier.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Flemington, NJ
Flemington is a small borough in Hunterdon County in west-central New Jersey, serving as the county seat and home to roughly 4,800 residents. The community has retained a distinctly 19th-century feel, with a compact, walkable downtown of preserved Victorian storefronts, giving it a main-street-America character that contrasts with the suburban sprawl typical of much of New Jersey. Best known for its outlet shopping and its place in American history as the site of the 1935 Lindbergh kidnapping trial, Flemington also functions as a gateway to the rolling farmland, state parks, and river valleys of Hunterdon County. It sits roughly 55 miles west of New York City and about 35 miles north of Trenton, well within reach of both major metropolitan areas while feeling a world away in atmosphere.
The historic downtown district along Main Street is the borough's social anchor, lined with independent boutiques, antique shops, restaurants, and the Hunterdon County Courthouse, the very building where the Hauptmann trial unfolded and which still stands at the heart of town. Visitors come for the small-town shopping and dining experience, and the courthouse itself draws a steady trickle of history-minded travelers. The downtown is essentially walkable from anywhere in the borough.
Just outside the center of town, Liberty Village Premium Outlets is one of the largest outlet shopping destinations in central New Jersey, drawing day-trippers from New York, Philadelphia, and the surrounding suburbs. It sits within a few minutes' drive of Main Street, which means a short-term rental in Flemington gives visitors a convenient base for combining outlet shopping with the more local experience of the historic district.
For outdoor recreation, Round Valley Recreation Area, about a 15-minute drive southwest of the borough, is one of New Jersey's most popular state parks, centered on a deep, spring-fed reservoir that supports swimming, fishing, boating, and hiking. The reservoir's striking blue waters ringed by forested ridges make it a notable contrast to the gentler farmland that surrounds Flemington, and it is a strong draw for vacationers seeking a few days of hiking, paddling, or simply escaping into nature.
A short drive north of Flemington, the town of Clinton is home to the Red Mill Museum Village, a cluster of restored 19th-century buildings set along the South Branch of the Raritan River. The picturesque red mill, stone blacksmith shop, and one-room schoolhouse have made it one of the most photographed historic sites in New Jersey and a popular family destination roughly 15 minutes from Flemington.
Flemington combines small-town charm, serious retail appeal, and quick access to state parks and historic river towns, all within an hour of both New York City and Philadelphia. That mix of walkable character, marquee attractions, and outdoor variety gives the borough a reliable year-round draw, making it a particularly versatile setting for a short-term rental that can host shoppers, leaf-peepers, and outdoor travelers alike.