Performance indicators for the Bailey Island short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Bailey Island.
Loading top listings...
Generally Investor friendly
STRs are currently allowed with no town-level caps, license, or registration, and the task force’s draft rules emphasize health/safety (septic, egress, trash) rather than supply limits—supporting a friendly environment. However, a registry, inspection, and fee program is expected in 2025, and investors must already meet state lodging tax, safety, and on-site septic constraints, which raise compliance costs and operational complexity.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Bailey Island, ME
Bailey Island is the southernmost of the inhabited islands that make up the coastal town of Harpswell, in Cumberland County, Maine. With a year-round population of just a few hundred residents, it has the feel of a traditional New England fishing village, where lobster boats still work the surrounding waters and weathered clapboard cottages line quiet lanes. The island serves as a gateway to the broader Casco Bay archipelago, a stretch of coastline beloved for its rugged scenery, working harbors, and slow-paced island atmosphere. Bailey Island sits roughly twenty miles northeast of Portland, Maine — the nearest major city — with a drive of about forty-five minutes to an hour, much of it along the scenic Route 1 corridor through Brunswick and Freeport.
The most iconic landmark here is the Cribstone Bridge, the unusual granite-slab span that connects Bailey Island to neighboring Orr's Island and, from there, the mainland. Completed in 1928 and listed on the National Register of Historic Places, the bridge was engineered with open cribs of granite that allow tidal water to flow freely between the bay below and the cove above, a clever design that has kept it standing through decades of punishing New England winters. Walking or driving across the bridge is part of the Bailey Island experience, both for the engineering curiosity and for the views out across Casco Bay.
At the southern tip of the island, the area known as Land's End draws visitors for its dramatic, wave-battered coastline, a long-running gift shop perched on the cliff, and the paths that lead to the Giant's Stairs — a natural rock formation of stepped basalt ledges that the ocean has polished over millennia. It is a popular spot for photography, picnicking, and watching boats pass through the bay, particularly at sunset. Just up the road, Mackerel Cove offers a small working harbor where visitors can often see lobster boats unloading their catch, along with a public float and a small beach that becomes a gathering place in the warmer months.
Within an easy drive, the wider region offers plenty of day-trip appeal. The town of Brunswick, home to Bowdoin College, sits roughly thirty minutes northwest, while Freeport — known for its outlet shopping and the flagship L.L.Bean store — is about twenty minutes away. Bath, a historic shipbuilding city on the Kennebec River, is roughly forty minutes north. Combined with Portland's cobblestone Old Port, lighthouses, and restaurants, these nearby destinations make Bailey Island a natural base for travelers who want a quiet, scenic island retreat with the rest of coastal Maine within easy reach.