Performance indicators for the Carrollton short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Carrollton.
Loading top listings...
Challenging to Investors
Carrollton effectively bans STRs unless they qualify as a motel in B‑2 (permitted, with certs and parking/bulk rules), a boarding house (special‑use in any district, requiring a public hearing and city‑imposed conditions), or an owner‑present home‑based STR (special‑use, strict limits and on‑site requirement). This means most typical STRs are prohibited without zoning changes, making permitting costly and uncertain, and raising investor risk due to limited eligible zones and discretionary approvals.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Carrollton, IL
Carrollton is a small city in west-central Illinois that serves as the county seat of Greene County. With a population of approximately 2,200 residents, it embodies the character of a classic Midwestern county seat, with a tidy courthouse square, tree-lined residential streets, and a pace of life shaped by agriculture and the surrounding river hills. The community has deep roots in Illinois history dating to the early nineteenth century, and it functions as a quiet local hub for the farms and small towns of Greene County. Carrollton sits roughly 70 miles northeast of St. Louis, Missouri, placing it within easy reach of a major metropolitan area while retaining the feel of a rural Illinois community.
A short drive south of Carrollton brings visitors to Pere Marquette State Park, one of the largest state parks in Illinois, situated along the Illinois River near the town of Grafton. The park encompasses wooded bluffs, river overlooks, and an extensive trail system used for hiking and horseback riding, and it is a popular destination for fall color tours. The drive from Carrollton to the park is roughly forty-five minutes to an hour, depending on route, making it feasible as a day trip for travelers staying in the area.
The broader region is defined by the Great River Road, a National Scenic Byway that traces the Mississippi River through much of western Illinois. From Carrollton, travelers can reach stretches of the byway within roughly an hour, winding through limestone bluffs, small river towns, and the bottomland forests where the Illinois and Mississippi rivers converge. The area draws outdoor enthusiasts for fishing, boating, and wildlife viewing, particularly in the bottomlands south of the city.
To the northeast, the state capital of Springfield is approximately 75 miles away, offering visitors access to Abraham Lincoln–related historic sites, the state capitol complex, and additional museum and dining options. The drive typically takes just over an hour, giving short-term rental guests an easy option for a day in the capital without the cost or congestion of an urban stay.
Carrollton's appeal as a base for short-term rentals lies in this balance of rural tranquility and regional access. Guests can settle into a small-town setting anchored by a historic courthouse square, then set out by day to explore state parks, scenic river byways, and nearby cities. For travelers who want to experience the Illinois River valley and the broader western Illinois landscape without the bustle of St. Louis or Springfield, Carrollton offers a comfortable and authentic alternative.