Performance indicators for the Island Park short-term rental market based on reliable data.
Listings
Reliable / Active
Cap Rate
Middle-Earners Gross Yield
Revenue
Middle-Earners Revenue
Occupancy
Middle-Earners Occupancy
Home Value
Median Home Sale Price
Top Earners
Top-Earners Revenue
The highest-performing listings in Island Park.
Loading top listings...
Very Investor friendly
Short-term rentals are clearly permitted citywide and countywide (HB 216 prevents bans), with straightforward permitting via Fremont County (Class 1 $200, Class 2 $500) and standard safety/operational requirements. Inspections are limited to septic and well every two years, taxes are handled by platforms, there are no caps on permits, and enforcement is complaint-driven and education-focused—minimal deterrents to investment.
Local STR Agent
STR specialist · Island Park, ID
Island Park is a small, resort-oriented community in Fremont County, Idaho, with a year-round population of only a few hundred residents, swelling considerably in summer and winter as visitors arrive for outdoor recreation. Set along the Henrys Fork of the Snake River, the town is best known as a gateway to the West Entrance of Yellowstone National Park and is often associated with the broader Yellowstone–Teton region of the upper Rocky Mountains. The nearest major city is Idaho Falls, which lies roughly 90 miles to the west, a drive of about two hours. Island Park has a relaxed, outdoorsy character shaped by fly fishing, snowmobiling trails, forested campgrounds, and a famously long "main street" that stretches more than thirty miles through the surrounding meadows and pine forest.
The single biggest draw in the area is Yellowstone National Park, whose West Entrance is only about twenty-five miles northeast of Island Park, a drive of roughly thirty minutes. From this entrance, visitors can reach iconic features such as the geyser basins of the Upper, Midway, and Lower loops, the Grand Canyon of the Yellowstone, and the wildlife-rich Lamar Valley, making the town a popular base for guests who want to explore the park without staying in the busier gateway communities on the Wyoming side. Many short-term-rental owners in Island Park market heavily to Yellowstone travelers during the peak summer season, when road construction in other parts of the park can make the West Entrance route especially appealing.
Just to the northeast of town, the Upper and Lower Mesa Falls offer a quieter but still memorable natural experience within the Caribou-Targhee National Forest. The two cascading waterfalls plunge over a hundred feet into the canyon of the Henrys Fork, and the overlook and short interpretive trails are roughly a thirty-minute drive from central Island Park. The area is particularly striking in autumn and in the snowmelt months of late spring.
Another nearby highlight is Harriman State Park, a large, river-anchored preserve known for its world-class blue-ribbon trout fishing on the Henrys Fork, as well as wildlife watching and groomed winter trails for cross-country skiing. It sits only a few miles north of Island Park along the river, making it a convenient stop for guests who want a Yellowstone-style experience of forests, water, and mountain views without the crowds of the main park.
In short, Island Park combines small-town quiet with rare proximity to one of America's most-visited national parks, supplemented by rivers, waterfalls, and state-park landscapes just minutes away. This mix of marquee tourism and accessible outdoor recreation makes it a strong fit for short-term-rental owners catering to Yellowstone road-trippers, fly-fishing enthusiasts, snowmobilers, and families looking for a quieter, forested alternative to the busier park gateways.